#ARCAugust + #ReadThemAllThon Review: Highly Illogical Behavior by John Corey Whaley + Top Quotes

I was lucky enough to win Highly Illogical Behavior in a prize stack of ARCs from YAWednesdays. When #ARCAugust rolled around and I still hadn't read it, I was resolved to do nothing but read my stack with this at the top. Then #ReadThemAllThon popped up and of course, I added it to the list as an extra bonus.

Right now, I'm just mad I didn't read it sooner and sad that I don't have a similar read to dive into right this second.

Basically: Good. Cute. Funny. Heartbreaking. Told in alternative perspectives by Solomon and Lisa. Progressive As Fuck.

Genre: Contemporary, QUILTBAG, Mental Health,
Age: YA
Format: ARC, 250pgs
Source: Won from YAWednesdays
Rating: 5 Stars
Recommendable? HELL YES
CW: Panic attacks,
Sixteen-year-old Solomon is agoraphobic. He hasn’t left the house in three years, which is fine by him.

Ambitious Lisa desperately wants to get into the second-best psychology program for college (she’s being realistic). But is ambition alone enough to get her in?

Enter Lisa.

Determined to “fix” Sol, Lisa steps into his world, along with her charming boyfriend, Clark, and soon the three form an unexpected bond. But, as Lisa learns more about Sol and he and Clark grow closer and closer, the walls they’ve built around themselves start to collapse and their friendships threaten to do the same.

ARCREVIEW IconYoung Adult IconContemporary IconQUILTBAG IconDiverse IconFed the Nerd IconLight and Fun IconRefreshing Icon
Progressive IconSmart & Funny Icon

It is obvious Solomon was going to find out about Lisa’s plan but I couldn’t stop reading. Everything was delightful. The plot might be mostly formulaic but the characters and how the tropes were flipped more than makes up for it.

I loved how the kind of but not really love trio turned out. It’s so refreshing! It deals with public perception, gender norms, and jealousy brilliantly. It’s not preachy or the point, it just is—gloriously.

I especially adore how it’s not a quick fix for Solomon. Before reading I was a bit worried it’d be another romance to the rescue but NOPE! His progress is authentic, in the baby steps sometimes going backwards way.

Support systems are important but you can have a great foundation and still struggle. The kids came in and made it better, but didn’t *poof* solve it. Therapy is great, there seriously needs to be more positive portrayals of it, but I don’t begrudge Solomon’s choice. I remember loathing it as a kid forced to go. (Now I’m kicking myself.)

Solomon is such a doll. I just wanted to come kick it with him, geek out, and play wingman. His panic attacks were hard to read because, as someone with an anxiety disorder, it’s perfectly portrayed. And the guilt over it being irrational when you have such a good life comparatively like Solomon’s…I relate so hard even though my life’s been much rockier. Those thoughts are just always there.

Lisa is complex, smart, and driven. She’s oblivious and stubborn when it comes to other people. She has the book smarts and the right manner when Solomon has an attack but she doesn’t get it. She does also come with gender norms, especially about Clark. However, through it all she’s likeable. I just wanted her to clue in. Her growth at the end is amazing. I love her essay but it doesn’t read like something would actually submit. Though I suppose that’s the point… Bonus: She doesn’t become a “slut” or swear off men because of her mother. No slut-shaming, yay!

Clark is an adorably nice guy. He is clueless like Lisa but more empathetic from the beginning. I like how he’s so secure in his manhood, and how he handled the romance threads between them all. Plus, it doesn’t bother trying to give a reason on why he doesn’t want to have sex. He doesn’t need one and his decision needs to be respected. Sexism hurts men too and I love this inclusion. He’s dreamy and understanding and how he makes it up to Solomon *dreamy sigh*

Solomon’s Parents: Parenting goals right here. At first, it’s a bit “Why aren’t you doing more?” but the reality of the situation crushes any doubts. It’s positive but not fake and perfectly perfect. I just want to hug them and come over for dinner.

Its great people have Spock to connect to, but it makes me sad how long it’s been and how that character is the one pop culture icon that’s relatable. Will the next generation finally have someone different? What happens if his Star Trek is too far gone for teens or they don’t like Sci-fi? (Is there someone else and I missed it? Please enlighten me!)

If you want a cute and funny and light and dramatic and realistic and diverse read (any or all of the above), you should seriously read Highly Illogical Behavior. I’m so happy to have read this. It’s such a relief to read something as great as this and NOT have to sigh or accept or rant about problematic aspects.

But, at home, Solomon wasn’t the muted listener he’d been at home. He was himself. And that was someone who Grant didn’t seem to like very much.
Pg. 15

“You’re like Lady Macbeth without the murder.”
Pg. 20

Now he knew it to be absolutely true: He had a friend. And he was absolutely terrified of her.
Pg. 65

“We’ve been playing video games for, like, five hours. I’m not proud, Lisa. But, also, I am proud?”
“It’s funny”, she said. “The second I start hanging out with a dorky recluse, you turn into one. What is this life?”
Pg. 88

Gossip works that way. It makes fools out of everyone but the source.
Pg. 157

The more Lisa thought about it, the less ridiculous that idea sounded to her. After all, wasn’t she just trying to run away from the little part of the world that scared her, too?
Pg. 188

“Just be careful, okay? Don’t get your feelings hurt too bad. We are who we are. You know that better than anyone.”
Pg .192

And despite spending most of her time thinking about leaving, Lisa wasn’t ready to go just yet.
Pg. 216

He was an astronaut without a suit, but he was still breathing.
Pg. 249


  1. Wonderful review. I really want to read this one. It sounds great, and I'm happy to hear that you enjoyed it so much. I'm sharing a link to your review on my blog on Tuesday - www.letsgetbeyondtolerance.blogspot.com


    1. Thank you so much! I'm flattered and love that round up. I'll be watching for more of those, what a great idea.

  2. This isn't really my genre (I pretty much just read SFF), but you have me seriously intrigued about this book. I really want to know what these very unique-sounding relationships/friendships are between these characters. And it sounds like the book covers so many different important topics and handles them well! I will have to consider this one. I've put it on my Amazon list so I won't forget about it :-)

    1. Yay! :D

      I hope the Trekkie nerd glory is enough to tie you over and the characters hook you. Let me know what you think if you read it, I'd love hear it.

  3. Aah! I had heard of this book before, but I didn't realize how good it was until just now. This is the first review I read for it. :D It's definitely going on my TBR. Thank you <3

    1. Awesome. I'd love to compare notes once you read it :D

  4. I've seen this around, but honestly, I didn't expect it to be so awesome!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...